The GUI vs. The CLI: Beyond the GUI for file transfers and directory syncing

I’ve always been on the fence when it comes to using a gui over the cli to transfer/update files on a remote server. For the majority of my work I use Fetch when I need to transfer or grab single files and sometimes I will even go as far as mirroring with Fetch to sync entire projects. There are better ways for sure, but I really wanted to see what else is out there and the benefits of each method/tool available (ones that don’t use a gui at all!). I decided to take to the tweeters in hopes that other developers would provide me with some feedback/opinions.

The Question

Dennis Gaebel

The Replies

Chris Van Patten


Tom Moitié

Hugo Giraudel

Matthew Morek

CLI Options

There are a few options when it come to transferrring files without a GUI. Here are some of the top transferring commands that I know of currently using the CLI

#Grabs files from a remote URI
wget [url to your remote resource]

# This command copies the files from a local machine to a remote server
scp ~/Desktop/letter.png username@remote-uri.whatever:~/var/
# Copy a file from remote to local machine
scp username@remote-uri.whatever:~/var/ ~/Desktop/

#sync files or directories from your machine to a remote server
# -r, -t and -v flags are shorthand for --recursive, --times (preserves timestamps), and --verbose
rsync -rtv ~/Sites/myWebApp username@remote-uri.whatever:~/var/

These 3 commands are the base to any file transfer from a terminal shell. It should be known that rsync is not the best at tracking files like Git can achieve by detecting when files are no longer present or changed from the original source. wget works great, but for single retrieval scenarios and one way communication -not to mention you need to know the URI any time you need to execute it. scp allows files to be copied to, from, or between different hosts. That means it works great at two way communication. It uses ssh for data transfer and provides the same authentication and same level of security as ssh. I don’t know about you, but scp and the rest of it sounds like a ton of typing compared to using a gui, but we still can’t sync an entire project or an array of sub directories properly. This is where SSH and POST HOOKS work great when using Git for deployment.

Dandelion for Deployment

I want to share with you a new workflow for deploying/pushing files and projects instead of using a gui for FTP/SFTP project/file transfers and syncing. This tool is gonna blow your mind. It’s called Dandelion and it will amaze you with its abilities and customization options. Just to be up front Dandelion has dependencies and yes there are quirks still so deal with it.

Dandelion is a deployment tool using SFTP to transfer, but via the cli and runs on Ruby. The reason you’ll want to give it a go is because you’ve run into scenarios where you wanna deploy your project and maybe you also want to deploy only certain files to a remote machine. Dandelion lets you control which files are mirrored and also takes it one step further by letting you config it for yourself. Simply running dandelion deploy from the cli pushes your project dir/files to your remote machine specified. I’ve come across a few glitches though so I wanted to share and also include how to get going with this wonderful tool so let’s get it installed shall we?.

Installing Dandelion

In order to run Dandelion we gottstah get it first right? Let’s visit Github and take a look at the repo

Currently as of this writing Dandelion only runs on ruby 1.9.3 so if you’re using rvm to do the task of version switching and managing simply run rvm list rubies. For me it looks like this…

grayghostvisuals at GrayGhostVisualsMacBookAir.local  ~
$ rvm list rubies

rvm rubies

   ruby-1.9.3-p392 [ x86_64 ]
=* ruby-2.0.0-p0 [ x86_64 ]
   ruby-2.0.0-p195 [ x86_64 ]

# => - current
# =* - current && default
#  * - default

As you can see my default is 2.0.0-p0 so I’ll need to choose the 1.9.3 version. In order to switch I need to run rvm use ruby-1.9.3-p392 which will switch me over to the Ruby version required for Dandelion at this time. Once we have the correct version of Ruby we need to install the gems. Once again I use rvm so I need to execute the command rvm create dandelion which gives me the gemset quarantined from other gemsets installed on my machine. Now I run gem install dandelion as the README explains and BOOM!

Side Note: Although the repo does not explicitly say this you will need another little piece to get going called net-sftp (2.1.1). This can be installed by running gem install net-sftp, but the cli will give you a warning so just do what it says.

Dandelion Going Further

Now that the sweat has cleared from our eyes after all this installation nonsense we can get down to the heart of the tool…deploying. Dandelion provides some cool tricks to make life simpler. For my current situation I’m using Fetch for my SFTP/FTP gui. Sometimes I use ssh to run a git pull command from my remote machine, but I don’t do much mirroring with something like rsync. Also with Fetch I mirror and then check the option to delete stray items that no longer exist. I’ve also tried doing a post hook with Github that works pretty well, but still no control over what I want to do the most -control the output of what is sent upstream to the live server.

I can use Dandelion’s config file properly titled dandelion.yml to tell dandelion what and what not to upload to my destintaion of choice. Pretty cool. So let’s say I have a project that looks something like the following…


With Dandelion I can say “Hey, When you upload those files to the server don’t upload the directory “protected”, but keep it in the repo for the team to share.” This way that directory stays on a private Github repo for instance, but keeps out of a client’s server. I think that deserves a high-five. Of course it’s easy to keep out dotfiles with FTP mirroring but what about that nasty little compass config file? the README? that’s not a dotfile is it? doesn’t look like one to me so let’s keep those items out of the client’s server too just for good measure using Dandelion’s config file.

Dandelion Config.yml

If you’re using Media Temple I suggest following closely with my setup below as I ran into a quirk where dandelion was deploying to the .home directory instead of my actual home directory until I found the solution in this issue.

# Required
# --------

scheme: sftp
username: XXXXXX
password: XXXXXX

# Optional
# --------
# Remote path
# When using w/MediaTemple make sure to have this path structure
# to avoid stuff going into a symlinked .home directory.
# Also the forward slash before “home” is very important to have.
path: /home/XXXXXX/var/
port: 22

# These files (from Git) will not be uploaded during a deploy
    - .gitignore
    - dandelion.yml
    - .sass-cache
    - codekit-config.json
    - config.rb
    - .gitattributes

# These files (from your working directory) will be uploaded on every deploy
# additional:
#    - dir/

As you’ve noticed in the config I can make sure certain directories are not sent and more importantly keep them in the repo for the team to share with one another.

Your Workflow?

Do you have another system you prefer or ways to make all this nonsense I’m doing even cooler? Let me know in the comments.


Deployment Apps

Dennis Gaebel

Design Technologist passionate for Open Source, SVG, Typography, Web Animation, Interaction Development & Pattern Based Design.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

show formatting examples
<pre class="language-[markup | sass | css | php | javascript | ruby | clike | bash]"><code>
…code example goes here…

You may use these HTML tags and attributes:

<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Comment Preview

  1. John Doe shouted this comment preview: